Breaking the Sound Barrier: Women in Play-By-Play Broadcasting

Lisa Byington, Kate Scott, and Jenny Cavnar

For years, the world of sports broadcasting, particularly play-by-play commentary, has been seen as a male-dominated field. The rhythmic call of the action, the poetic narration of a fast-paced game, and the encyclopedic knowledge of teams and players have traditionally been associated with male voices. However, women in play-by-play broadcasting are increasingly breaking through barriers, proving not only their capability but their unique perspective and talent in bringing games to life for audiences around the world.

The Evolution of Women in Broadcasting

Historically, women in sports broadcasting were relegated to roles on the sidelines, conducting post-game interviews, or reporting from the studio. While these roles were vital in shaping the narrative of sports coverage, the play-by-play booth was often deemed off-limits. This was partly due to traditional stereotypes about gender and sports knowledge, as well as societal expectations about whose voice “belonged” in the world of sports.

In the 1970s and 1980s, pioneers such as Lesley Visser and Gayle Sierens began to break these molds. Sierens, in 1987, became the first woman to call an NFL game on network television, a milestone that set the stage for generations to come. Though her breakthrough was monumental, it would be decades before women would consistently have opportunities in play-by-play roles.

Why Play-By-Play Matters

Play-by-play broadcasters are the narrators of the action, the heartbeat of the game, and the link between the fans and the sport. They provide context, create excitement, and paint vivid pictures with words. The significance of women in these roles cannot be overstated.

Having women in play-by-play commentary diversifies the voices in sports, providing fresh perspectives and relatable representation for the growing number of female fans and athletes. This shift isn't just about inclusion; it’s about recognizing talent and expanding the storytelling tapestry of sports.

The Trailblazers

Suzyn Waldman, Hannah Storm and Andrea Kremer, Beth Mowins

The breakthrough came when women entered the play-by-play booth. While the road has been long, there are notable figures who have paved the way:

1. Suzyn Waldman: Known as the voice of the New York Yankees, Waldman was one of the first women to provide analysis in Major League Baseball. Her career inspired other women to break into sports commentary roles that were previously unavailable to them.

   
   

2. Beth Mowins: In 2017, Beth Mowins became the first woman in 30 years to call an NFL game on network television. Her precise and engaging commentary challenged stereotypes and demonstrated that knowledge, not gender, defines success in the booth.

   
   

3. Hannah Storm and Andrea Kremer: In 2018, Storm and Kremer became the first all-woman team to call an NFL game, showcasing how women can excel not only individually but as collaborative voices in sports.

   
   

4. Kate Scott: Kate Scott has made significant strides in hockey and basketball, becoming the play-by-play announcer for the Philadelphia 76ers in 2021. Her seamless delivery and understanding of the game have earned her respect from fans and colleagues alike.

   
   

Challenges Faced by Women in Play-By-Play

For many years, the exclusion of women from play-by-play broadcasting stemmed from deep-seated stereotypes. Women were often considered unsuitable for roles that required a commanding voice, encyclopedic knowledge of sports, and an ability to thrive under pressure. Those who aspired to such roles faced skepticism from fans, colleagues, and decision-makers in the industry.

The journey for women in play-by-play broadcasting has been anything but easy. Some of the challenges they face include:

• Bias and Stereotyping: Women often have to prove their knowledge and competence repeatedly in ways that their male counterparts do not.

  
  

• Limited Opportunities: Despite progress, women are still underrepresented in major league play-by-play roles, with men overwhelmingly dominating these positions.

  
  

• Online Harassment: Female broadcasters frequently face disproportionate scrutiny and abuse on social media platforms, which can discourage newcomers from pursuing the profession.

  
  

• Breaking the "Traditional Voice" Mold: Many fans are accustomed to hearing male voices in the booth, and women must work to reshape expectations about what a play-by-play announcer should sound like.

  
  

Despite these successes, women in play-by-play broadcasting continue to face unique challenges. They are often subject to heightened scrutiny and criticism, particularly on social media. Viewers may focus more on their voices, appearance, or perceived expertise than on their actual performance.

Moreover, the lack of representation in the field can create a sense of isolation. Women often find themselves as the only female voice in the booth or among production teams, which can amplify the pressure to excel.

Turning the Tide: Success Stories and Initiatives

Jamie Hersch, Jenn Hildreth, and Jessica Mendoza

The presence of women in play-by-play roles is growing, thanks to deliberate efforts by leagues and networks to create opportunities and mentorship programs.

• WNBA and Women's Soccer: Women like Lisa Byington and Jenn Hildreth have excelled in calling games for the WNBA and women's soccer, demonstrating their versatility and expertise.

• ESPN's Commitment: Networks like ESPN have made strides in hiring women for high-profile events, such as Jessica Mendoza’s groundbreaking role in MLB broadcasts. Programs like ESPN's "Voices of the Game" have highlighted the contributions of women and encouraged aspiring broadcasters to pursue their dreams.

• Local Broadcasting: Many women are cutting their teeth in local and regional broadcasting roles, which serve as stepping stones to national prominence.

  
  

The Impact of Representation

Representation matters in every field, and sports broadcasting is no exception. Young girls who dream of becoming the voice of a game can now look up to women who have achieved that dream. Representation in play-by-play roles also normalizes women as authoritative figures in sports, challenging the outdated notion that sports knowledge is a male domain.

The presence of women in play-by-play broadcasting matters for several reasons. First, it challenges outdated stereotypes about gender roles in sports and media. When young girls hear women calling games, it expands their horizons and shows them that their voices matter, too.

Second, diversity in the broadcast booth enhances the viewing experience for fans. Different perspectives bring fresh insights, stories, and styles of narration, enriching the way audiences experience sports.

Finally, women in play-by-play broadcasting help normalize the idea of women as authoritative figures in sports. Their voices are a powerful reminder that passion, knowledge, and skill transcend gender.

Looking Ahead: The Future of Women in Play-By-Play

Pien Meulensteen, Kenzie Lalonde, and Zora Stephenson

As the barriers continue to fall, the future for women in play-by-play broadcasting looks brighter than ever. Here are some key factors contributing to this progress:

1. Changing Demographics of Sports Fans: With women making up nearly half of sports fans, the demand for diverse voices that resonate with all audiences is stronger than ever.

   
   

2. Advocacy and Mentorship: Organizations like Women in Sports and Events (WISE) and initiatives within networks are mentoring the next generation of female broadcasters, ensuring that talent doesn’t go unnoticed.

   
   

3. Technology and Digital Platforms: The rise of streaming services and online platforms has created more opportunities for women to showcase their skills, bypassing traditional gatekeepers.

   
   

4. Shifting Attitudes: As fans become more accustomed to hearing women in the booth, acceptance grows, paving the way for future talent to thrive without the burden of breaking barriers.

   
   

While progress has been made, there is still work to be done. Networks must continue to invest in recruiting, training, and supporting women in play-by-play broadcasting. Fans can play their part by embracing diverse voices and challenging stereotypes in their communities.

Women in play-by-play broadcasting are not just breaking barriers—they are redefining what it means to be a sports broadcaster. Their voices are changing the game, one call at a time, and inspiring the next generation to follow in their footsteps.

Conclusion

Women in play-by-play broadcasting are no longer the exception; they are becoming the norm. While challenges remain, the achievements of trailblazers and the growing support from leagues, networks, and audiences are building momentum for a more inclusive future.

As the sports world continues to evolve, so too will its storytellers. Women in play-by-play broadcasting are not just narrating the action; they’re shaping the narrative of what sports can be—a space where talent, passion, and knowledge transcend gender, inspiring all who tune in.